Mutual funds are widely regarded as a means for diversified and risk-managed investing, but do they invest in high-risk penny stocks? Penny stocks, often characterised by their low price and small market capitalisation, carry significant volatility and liquidity risks, making them a challenging choice for large institutional investors. While most mutual funds tend to avoid them due to regulatory constraints and fiduciary responsibilities, some small-cap and micro-cap funds may have indirect exposure.
This blog explores whether mutual funds invest in penny stocks, the extent of their involvement, and the key factors influencing their investment decisions.
What are Penny Stocks?
While there is no strict regulatory definition, penny stocks are broadly understood as stocks trading at a low price, often below ₹100. Some consider only stocks under ₹50, ₹20, or even ₹10 as penny stocks. Unlike blue-chip stocks, these companies have smaller market valuations and are often in early-stage or less-established industries.
Key Characteristics
- Penny stocks experience high price volatility and low liquidity, making large transactions challenging.
- They often belong to financially weak companies with limited historical data and lower regulatory oversight.
- Most penny stocks are classified as small-cap or micro-cap, with some having large outstanding shares.
- They primarily trade on NSE and BSE, including SME and trade-to-trade segments.
- Institutional participation is limited, resulting in lower liquidity and wider bid-ask spreads.
Why do some Investors find Penny Stocks attractive?
1. Potential for High Returns
Penny stocks attract investors due to their potential for rapid price appreciation. Since these stocks trade at low prices, even small absolute gains can translate into significant percentage returns.
2. Low Initial Investment
With prices often below ₹50 or even ₹10, penny stocks offer an entry point for investors with limited capital. This affordability allows individuals to buy a large number of shares with a relatively small investment, making them psychologically appealing, even if the risks remain high.
3. Speculation and Risk Appetite
Many investors are drawn to penny stocks because of their speculative nature. Their volatility enables short-term trading opportunities, where prices can fluctuate significantly within days or even hours. Risk-tolerant traders often attempt to capitalise on these price swings, though the potential for loss is equally high.
4. Stories of Massive Wealth Creation
The lure of penny stocks is further fueled by success stories of stocks that started at extremely low prices and later surged to substantial valuations. Lists of “multibagger penny stocks” often highlight past examples where investors made extraordinary gains, creating a sense of excitement and optimism among those hoping to identify the next breakout stock.
Mutual Funds and Penny Stocks
In India, the Securities and Exchange Board of India (SEBI) does not provide a strict definition of penny stocks and does not outright ban mutual funds from investing in them.
Most mainstream mutual funds avoid penny stocks due to fiduciary responsibilities and investment mandates focusing on stability and liquidity. However, regulations mandate that small-cap mutual funds invest at least 65% of their assets in companies ranked below the top 250 by market capitalisation. This means some mutual funds may have indirect exposure to stocks that fit the broad definition of penny stocks.
Small-cap and micro-cap funds typically invest in companies that meet minimum financial and governance standards. SEBI actively monitors trading patterns in this segment to prevent fraud and market manipulation, further discouraging large-scale institutional investments in penny stocks.
How Mutual Funds Mitigate These Risks
1. Diversification
Mutual funds spread investments across multiple stocks and sectors to minimise the impact of any single underperforming asset. Even when exposed to penny stocks or small-cap companies, their diversified portfolios ensure that losses from individual stocks do not significantly affect overall returns.
2. Professional Management
Experienced fund managers actively monitor market trends, company performance, and risk factors to make informed investment decisions. Unlike retail investors who may act on speculation, mutual funds rely on data-driven strategies to navigate the risks associated with smaller, volatile stocks.
3. Thorough Due Diligence
Before investing in small or micro-cap stocks, mutual funds conduct extensive research, including financial analysis, business model evaluation, and risk assessments. This process helps filter out companies with poor fundamentals, reducing exposure to stocks prone to price manipulation or financial instability.
4. Limited Exposure
Most mutual funds avoid significant exposure to penny stocks due to their unpredictable nature and high volatility. Even small-cap and micro-cap funds, which are more likely to invest in lower market capitalisation stocks, allocate only a fraction of their portfolios to such companies.
Wrapping Up
While mutual funds generally avoid direct investment in penny stocks due to their volatility, some small-cap and micro-cap funds may have exposure to stocks with similar characteristics. These funds selectively invest in smaller companies with growth potential while mitigating risks through diversification and strict selection criteria.
Investing in penny stocks offers the potential for high returns but comes with significant risks, including price manipulation, low liquidity, and financial instability. Mutual funds provide a structured approach to investing in smaller companies by balancing risk with professional management and portfolio diversification.
Investors should conduct thorough research, assess their risk tolerance, and consult financial advisors before investing in penny stocks or small-cap funds. A well-informed approach, combined with a diversified investment strategy, can help manage risks while taking advantage of potential growth opportunities in the small-cap segment.
Interested in how we think about the markets?
Read more: Zen And The Art Of Investing
Watch here: Learn about the F&O craze in India
