Taxation is what keeps civilization afloat. However, not all taxpayers follow the same set of regulations. The wealthy and well-connected have evaded paying trillions of dollars in taxes with the assistance of attorneys, accountants, white-shoe specialists, and complicit Western governments. The rest of us make up the difference — or, more often, cannot leave treasuries short of funds required to develop roads, schools, and combat existential dangers like climate change and worldwide pandemics.
According to some estimates, nearly 10% of the total output of the world’s economies is stored in offshore financial hubs by shell corporations that exist only on paper. The annual cost to governments in lost income is projected to be more than $800 billion.
The affluent keep the money to build intergenerational fortunes, establishing a new global aristocracy and aggravating the global haves and have-nots.
Multinational corporations use the additional cash to reward shareholders and gain a competitive advantage over smaller competitors.
Countries that require the greatest tax revenue lose more tax money as a percentage of GDP than affluent countries. As with other inequities, the poor bear the brunt of the consequences.
Years after the Panama Papers, the International Consortium of Investigative Journalists is still dedicated to exposing those who take advantage of tax havens — a long list that includes corrupt politicians, mobsters, drug traffickers, and other criminals who launder money and assets through offshore companies to avoid detection by law enforcement. The free flow of illegal funds destabilises regimes and aids despots in maintaining power.
What Is Tax Haven?
In a politically and economically secure climate, a tax haven is a country that offers foreign individuals and companies limited or no tax responsibility for bank deposits. They contain tax benefits for companies and the very rich, as well as the apparent potential for abuse in criminal tax avoidance schemes.
Companies and wealthy individuals may legitimately utilise tax havens to stash money generated overseas while avoiding higher taxes in other countries.
Tax havens can also be used illegally to hide money from domestic tax authorities. The tax haven can do this by refusing to cooperate with international tax officials. Tax havens have recently been under increased worldwide political pressure to help with foreign tax fraud investigations.
How Tax Haven Works?
A hypothetical case study can help you understand how a tax haven works. Assume Banana Inc, is a massive multinational US-based firm located in California that generates extraordinary profits globally and is subject to the corporate tax band of 30% under US tax laws.
- Banana now forms Mango Ltd, a shell corporation in Jersey, a popular tax haven destination for US corporations, including Apple Inc, that does not carry out any trade or commerce operations and does not hold any substantial asset.
- Banana transfers its earnings, property rights, and other significant interests to Mango Ltd, rendering income made in the United States taxable within Jersey’s Tax Jurisdiction. Jersey does not normally tax company income.
- Banana Inc has so effectively avoided paying a 30% tax.
Remember that taxes are the sole source of government revenue and their legal right. The practices of Banana Inc. are a tax law loophole that violates the US government’s legal authority.
- Exceptionally Low Tax Rates
Tax Haven offers or levies little taxes on earnings produced inside their jurisdiction; this varies per country. However, there is a little fee for the services they provide.
- Information Secrecy
The other most significant characteristic of a tax haven is that they secure its clients’ personal and financial information with great credibility. No information is shared with foreign tax authorities without the client’s authorization.
- Inadequate Transparency
The most serious issue with offshore financial hubs is that their structure is completely opaque. National governments are not even given financial information. As a result, the system is abused for tax evasion and other criminal activities, such as money laundering.
- No Substantial Activities Required
Outside entities are not required to produce products or services within the jurisdiction of a tax haven. Entities can avoid having their revenues and wealth generated in tax-paying nations taxed under their jurisdiction by simply establishing their headquarters in tax havens or shifting substantial financial transactions to subsidiaries or shell firms based in tax havens. For example, you can start your business in India and be subject to taxation in Singapore.
Advantages Of Tax Haven
The following are some of the key benefits of Tax Havens-
- The major advantage of Tax Havens is the potential for companies to save money and pay fewer taxes.
- Saving taxes is both logical and lawful. The investment is safe since there are no tax repercussions in the country, which is regarded as a Tax Haven.
- Tax Havens also benefit the economy tremendously since they encourage fresh investment, which is beneficial to the entire country.
- They start the development of both an individual and a country.
- Because there are no capital gains taxes, businessmen are incentivized to invest.
Disadvantages Of Tax Havens
Tax havens, like any other topic, have various problems, which are discussed more below-
- Tax havens may also encourage unlawful activities.
- Tax havens can be highly beneficial, but they can also extract an expansion coefficient from residents by imposing a high import tariff on imported items.
- Because the Tax Havens procedure is opaque, the parties may be vulnerable to treachery.
- Tax Haven business transactions are frequently made up and may deceive the other party.
Top Tax Havens in the World
- Bermuda – Oxfam named it the world’s worst (or greatest if you want to dodge taxation) corporate tax haven in 2016 with a 0% tax rate and no personal income tax.
- Netherlands –The most favoured tax haven among the Fortune 500. Tax breaks are used by the government to entice firms to invest in their nation. In 2016, the Netherlands paid an estimated 1.2 billion euros for one such tax benefit.
- Luxembourg – In addition to being one of the richest countries in the world right now, Luxembourg has long been considered as a favourite Tax Haven. It continues to be a financial powerhouse despite the EU’s most recent attempts to harm the nation’s reputation as a Tax Haven on the world stage.
- Cayman Islands – The Cayman Islands are a preferred choice for both corporations and financiers since they are possibly the best tax haven in the whole globe. The absence of corporation taxes in this nation is a nice perk that business organisations use to avoid paying expensive and burdensome taxes.
- Singapore –Corporate taxes are regarded as low-level in this wealthy and strong country. A very successful economic powerhouse, Singapore is thought to have a GDP of over $1 trillion. Singapore is the hub of trade, industry, and the regional economy, therefore it allows investors and enterprises to pay fewer taxes.
- Channel Islands –There are no capital gains taxes, council taxes, or value-added taxes.
- The Isle Of Man- No capital gains, turnover tax, or capital transfer taxes. It also has a low income tax, with the highest rates standing at 20%.
- Mauritius – Because of its extraordinary isolation, it is not surprising that Mauritius, an island nation in the Indian Ocean, has grown into a Tax Haven. The great majority of Indian enterprises take advantage of this tax break. While there is a corporation tax in Mauritius, firms with headquarters in the United States or Europe can take advantage of special tax legislation.
- The Bahamas – The Bahamas in the Caribbean are the ideal place for businesses because there are no taxes there at all. For prominent enterprises, it is a huge gift.
- Malta – The smallest EU member, the island nation of Malta, has the lowest tax load. Individuals are less suited to Malta than enterprises, and because of its positive reputation, businesses choose Malta.
- Switzerland – The Swiss are arguably most recognised for their efficient and functional financial institutions, which have remained neutral throughout times of strife. When it comes to Tax Havens situated abroad, the country is well-known for consistently being trustworthy. It is popular with Europeans and clients from other nations.
- Ireland – Despite officials’ claims to the contrary, it is referred regarded as a tax haven. Apple determined that despite being established in Ireland, two of the company’s Irish companies were not recognised as tax residents in either the United States or Ireland.
Leading Tax Haven Beneficiaries According To Database Provided By U.S.
- Apple – Apple’s offshore bookings total $214.9 billion. It takes advantage of Ireland as a tax shelter. If Apple had not exploited tax havens, it would have repaid the US government $65.4 billion in taxes.
- Nike – It has $10.7 billion in offshore assets. Bermuda is used as a tax shelter. If tax haven benefits had not been utilised, it would have paid $3.6 billion in taxes. This suggests that Nike only pays a 1.4% tax rate to foreign governments on its offshore income, implying that practically all of the money is retained in tax havens via subsidiaries.
- Goldman Sachs- Goldman Sachs has $28.6 billion in offshore assets and utilises Bermuda as a tax haven.
Microsoft, IBM, General Electric, Pfizer, Exxon Mobil, Chevron, and Walmart are among the 50 largest US corporations that have hidden about $1.6 trillion overseas. These 50 firms made over $4.2 trillion in revenues worldwide, but they exploited offshore tax havens to reduce their effective total tax rate to just 25.9%, significantly below the 35% statutory rate in the United States and much lower than the average levels paid in other industrialised nations.
Conclusion
The existence of Tax Havens has several consequences. One way to look at it is that countries with no or low taxes exert pressure on other countries to keep their taxes low. The possible long-term harm to the global economy exceeds the short-term benefits for taxpayers from money laundering and other illicit activity promoted by the secrecy and opacity of some Tax Havens.
Taxpayers should proceed with prudence, as indicated by actions taken against tax evaders in several countries.
FAQs
-
What Motivates A Country Or State To Become A Tax Haven?
Money. Tax havens profit significantly from fees paid by individuals and businesses who establish and use shell corporations. Lawyers, accountants, and secretaries are also employed in tax havens. Mauritius, for example, has stated that if the country stopped being a tax haven, 5,000 people would lose their employment.
-
What Exactly Is A “Shell” Company?
A shell corporation is a legal entity that is established in a tax haven. Shell corporations usually exist solely on paper, with no full-time staff and no physical location. In the Cayman Islands, for example, a single office building houses 19,000 shell businesses. Although the rules vary, the true proprietors of many shells are not revealed in incorporation forms. Some people confuse the terms “shell company” and “offshore company.”
-
Who And Why Utilise Tax Havens?
Rich but otherwise “average” people use shell companies for a variety of reasons, including making it more difficult for potential creditors – such as tax inspectors to identify and recoup extra funds allegedly owed.
Tax shelter investments can be extremely profitable due to the large tax savings that offshore corporations may enjoy.
ICIJ has linked the likes of Bob Geldof, Madonna, and US Commerce Secretary Wilbur Ross to shell corporations. Some, such as Queen Elizabeth II, claim they have no idea they have offshore investments.
Politicians such as Iceland’s former prime minister, Sigmundur David Gunnlaugsson, and Nigeria’s former senate president, Bukola Saraki, have used shell corporations to conceal assets or luxury houses. Their children have done the same. The son and daughter of former Pakistan Prime Minister Nawaz Sharif, as well as Isabel dos Santos, the millionaire daughter of former Angolan strongman President Jose Eduardo dos Santos, are notables.
Shell corporations are also used by drug lords and ladies, bank robbers and arms traffickers, mafia kingpins and queens, and bribe-takers and manufacturers to disguise their names and money, assets, and unlawful operations.
-
Is It Unlawful To Own Or Use A Shell Company?
The simple answer is no. The lengthier answer is that it depends on how the shell corporation is utilised and where it is formed or incorporated. While hiding stolen assets overseas is obviously unlawful, purchasing a fancy boat through a shell corporation may not be. Lawyers and accountants excel at suggesting theoretically lawful methods to spend or store money overseas.
-
How Do Tax Havens Benefit Companies?
Businesses, particularly those that do cross-border transactions, can save significantly on taxes by channelling payments, earnings, or investments through subsidiaries in offshore financial hubs.
A large pharmaceutical corporation, for example, may establish a new business in Bermuda or the Netherlands and “sell” a patent for a profitable medicine to that entity. The parent business may then pay a large licence fee to the offshore subsidiary, allowing it to declare lesser earnings at home – and hence pay a smaller tax bill. According to Oxfam, drug firms have saved billions of dollars in taxes this way.
Companies use strategies like this to avoid paying more than $500 billion in taxes each year. Some pay very little or no taxes in their own nations.
Apple, Johnson & Johnson, and Skype are examples of notable corporate tax evaders.
Corporations frequently claim that shell companies stimulate foreign investment and facilitate transactions that would not otherwise be possible. Many people say they incorporate abroad to avoid paying taxes twice on the same amount of money. According to experts, such defences are either exaggerated or fictional.
-
What Exactly Is A Nominated Director And What Do They Do?
A nominee director is someone or a firm who is paid to appear on official paperwork. To prevent public exposure, shell firms might appoint nominees, often known as dummies, as directors instead of the company’s genuine owner (or owners). Nominees undertake administrative functions, such as signing minutes of company meetings but have no actual or legal power or influence over the shell business.
Interested in how we think about the markets?
Read more: Zen And The Art Of Investing
Check out all our “Investor Education Originals” videos on Youtube and get smart about investing.
Start investing through a platform that brings goal planning and investing to your fingertips. Visit kuvera.in to discover Direct Plans and Fixed Deposits and start investing today.
#MutualFundSahiHai #KuveraSabseSahiHai #PersonalFinance #InvestorEducation;
