When selecting the best mutual funds for their portfolio, investors tend to look at the previous one-year or three-year mutual fund’s past performance aka returns. However, relying solely on past returns can lead to misleading conclusions. So, is it that history doesn’t repeat itself in mutual funds?
Let’s find out.
In this blog, we’ll examine why past performance is not a reliable predictor of future success for mutual funds and highlight key factors to consider when evaluating mutual funds India. This analysis draws upon research and insights from a leading mutual fund research and analysis firm in India.
Ten Key Reasons Why Past Performance Doesn’t Guarantee Future Success in Mutual Funds
1. Market Volatility
The inherent volatility of financial markets means that past performance is rarely a reliable indicator of future trends. Market conditions are constantly evolving, influenced by a multitude of factors such as economic growth, interest rates, political events, global events (like the 2022 Russia-Ukraine war, which impacted markets worldwide), and investor sentiment. A fund that performed well in a bull market might struggle in a bear market and vice-versa.
For instance, Value Research data from their “Mutual Fund Performance Review 2008” showed that many equity funds that had delivered double-digit mutual fund returns in the preceding years suffered significant losses during the 2008 financial crisis, highlighting the impact of market volatility on fund performance.
2. Changing Economic Landscape
Economic cycles, government policies, and global events can significantly impact mutual fund returns. A fund that thrives in a specific economic environment might not replicate its success when the landscape changes.
For example, a Value Research analysis of sector performance in their “Sectoral Trends Report 2023” revealed that funds focused on the pharmaceutical sector, which performed well during the COVID-19 pandemic, experienced a slowdown in mutual fund return as the pandemic subsided and the focus shifted to other sectors.
3. Fund Manager Changes
A fund manager’s expertise and strategic decisions are crucial to a fund’s performance. Changes in fund management can significantly alter a fund’s investment style and risk profile, impacting future mutual fund returns. A fund that delivers consistent returns under a particular manager might experience a shift in performance if a new manager with a different philosophy takes over.
For instance, if a growth-oriented manager replaces a value-oriented manager, the fund’s investment strategy and holdings could change significantly, affecting its future performance.
4. Investment Style Drift
Over time, a fund manager might deviate from their original investment style or mandate. This “style drift” can lead to unexpected changes in the fund’s risk profile and mutual fund return.
For example, a large-cap fund that gradually increases its allocation to mid-cap or small-cap stocks in pursuit of higher returns might expose investors to higher volatility and potentially lower mutual fund returns during market downturns. This drift can occur due to various reasons, such as changes in market conditions, the manager’s evolving views, or pressure to outperform benchmarks.
5. Survivor Bias
When analysing historical data, investors often fall prey to survivor bias. This bias arises from focusing only on funds that have survived and performed well, ignoring those that have been liquidated or merged due to poor performance. This creates a distorted picture of past performance, leading to inflated expectations for mutual fund returns. It is essential to consider the performance of all funds, including those that have failed, to get an accurate picture of the industry’s track record.
6. Lack of Predictive Power
Numerous studies have shown that past performance has little to no predictive power for future mutual fund returns. Academic research, including studies by S&P Dow Jones Indices and CRISIL, has consistently demonstrated no reliable correlation between a fund’s past performance and its future performance. This means that even if a fund has performed exceptionally well in the past, there’s no guarantee that it will continue to do so in the future.
Pro Tip: Create wealth with SIP. Start now.
7. Focus on the Wrong Metrics
Investors often fixate on short-term performance metrics, such as one-year or three-year returns, which can be misleading. Temporary market fluctuations can influence short-term performance and might not reflect the fund’s long-term potential. A more holistic approach involves analysing the fund’s performance over different market cycles (including bull and bear markets), considering its risk-adjusted returns, and comparing it to its benchmark and peers.
8. Ignoring Risk
Chasing past performance often leads investors to overlook the risk associated with a particular fund. A fund that delivered high mutual fund returns in the past might have taken on higher risk, which could result in significant losses in the future. It’s crucial to assess a fund’s risk profile, considering its investment strategy, portfolio concentration, and volatility, and ensure it aligns with your investment goals and risk tolerance.
9. Emotional Decision-Making
Relying solely on past performance can lead to emotional decision-making. Investors might be tempted to chase high-performing funds, ignoring their underlying fundamentals and long-term prospects. This can result in buying high and selling low, leading to poor mutual fund return. It is essential to approach investing with a rational mindset, focusing on a fund’s long-term potential and alignment with your investment objectives rather than being swayed by short-term performance trends.
10. Neglecting Other Important Factors
Focusing solely on past performance can distract investors from other crucial factors, such as the fund’s investment strategy, expense ratio, fund manager’s experience, and the fund house’s reputation. These factors can significantly impact a fund’s long-term success and should be considered alongside historical performance. For example, a fund with a high expense ratio might erode your mutual fund return over time, even if it has a strong track record.
Wrapping Up
While past performance can provide insights into a fund’s historical track record, it should not be the sole determinant of investment decisions. A complex interplay of factors influences mutual fund returns, and past performance is rarely a reliable predictor of future success. A more prudent approach involves conducting thorough research, considering various factors, and focusing on the fund’s long-term potential rather than chasing short-term gains.
Adopting a holistic and informed approach to investing can increase your chances of achieving your financial goals and maximising your mutual fund return in the long run.
Interested in how we think about the markets?
Read more: Zen And The Art Of Investing
Watch here: Is UPI Killing the Toffee Business?
